The Accidental Consultant

A blog for consultants, money managers, and their clients to discuss the state of the industry and current market conditions - and for me to publish my thoughts.

My Photo
Name:
Location: Los Angeles, CA

Monday, April 03, 2006

Foundation Accuses TH Lee Putnam Of Inflating Portfolio Value

Here's a good story: A foundation suing over inflated values in a VC fund. Expect to see more of this. It is not just the Private Equity firms that have an interest in inflating values. The largest clients of the PE firms do as well. Inflated values give pension plan sponsors lots of wiggle room on plan funding. Also, the biggest endowments (such as the large Universities) who have plowed huge percentages into private equity have a lot at stake. The endowment managers have become heroes in the last few years generating high returns.

If you are a hotshot manager at Harvard or Stanford, and you have posted fantastic returns by being invested in illiquid assets (not marked to market) vs. liquid assets (marked to market) do you really want to make sure that your illiquid assets are being valued correctly? In my archives, you will see that I have already predicted that the large exodus of talent from the top universities is a result of "getting out at the top". This lawsuit is the first sign of what is to come.

I am always suspect of returns in illiquid markets, and I wouldn't be surprised at all that if these endowments haven't done nearly as well as they claim.

http://snipurl.com/olwq

  • OK, I think I need to add here that I am not in any way shape or form advocating for or against any particular investment or investment style. The world of consulting rapidly changes, and this forum is designed to help all participants in the marketplace by serving as a location for the exchange of ideas. I have a clients who have an interest in the outcome of particular investment strategies, and thus I do as well. All investors have different needs, and thus investments that I might pan for some might be appropriate for others